What Made Them the Best?

2017 saw a continued trend towards more nuanced and morally gray protagonists. The days of the purely good-hearted hero were certainly not over, but characters grappling with internal conflict, past trauma, and difficult choices became increasingly prevalent and celebrated. This complexity invited deeper engagement from the audience, fostering a sense of connection that transcended simple admiration.

Saitama (One-Punch Man Season 2 - Though technically aired in 2019, his impact from earlier seasons and the anticipation for more cemented his presence in discussions of iconic male characters. We're looking at the spirit of characters that defined the era.)

While One-Punch Man's second season aired later, Saitama's enduring popularity and the cultural conversation around him were undeniable in 2017. His existential ennui, born from overwhelming power, offered a unique comedic and philosophical angle. He wasn't just strong; he was bored. This relatable human flaw, albeit amplified to absurd levels, made him incredibly endearing. His quest for a challenge, a genuine struggle, mirrored a common human desire for meaning and purpose. Did Saitama truly find it? The answer, as always, remained hilariously elusive.

Izuku Midoriya (My Hero Academia Season 2)

Deku's journey in 2017 was one of profound growth. Taking on the mantle of One For All, he grappled with the immense pressure and responsibility that came with his Quirk. His unwavering determination, even when facing overwhelming odds and his own self-doubt, was inspiring. We witnessed him push his limits, not just physically, but mentally and emotionally. His interactions with rivals like Katsuki Bakugo and mentors like All Might provided crucial character development. Deku’s arc is a masterclass in perseverance, demonstrating that true strength lies not just in power, but in the will to protect others. His evolution throughout the year solidified his place among the best anime male characters 2017 had to offer.

Guts (Berserk - The 2016/2017 anime adaptation)

The 'Black Swordsman' continued his brutal and relentless journey in 2017. Guts is the epitome of a character forged in the fires of unimaginable suffering. His relentless pursuit of Griffith, fueled by a thirst for vengeance, is a dark and compelling narrative. What makes Guts so captivating is his sheer resilience in the face of absolute despair. He endures physical and psychological torment that would break any ordinary person, yet he continues to fight. His struggle isn't just against demons and apostles, but against his own inner demons, the rage and trauma that threaten to consume him. This internal battle is what elevates him beyond a simple revenge-driven protagonist.

2017 also showcased the enduring appeal of characters who operate in the gray areas, blurring the lines between good and evil. These characters often possess compelling motivations, making their actions, however questionable, understandable, if not justifiable.

Light Yagami (Death Note - While the series is older, its themes and characters remain eternally relevant and were frequently revisited in fan discussions and retrospectives in 2017.)

Though Death Note concluded years prior, Light Yagami's complex character continued to be a benchmark for morally ambiguous figures in anime. His descent from a brilliant, albeit arrogant, student into a megalomaniacal killer driven by a twisted sense of justice is a cautionary tale. Was he a hero or a villain? The answer depends entirely on your perspective. His intellectual battles with L were legendary, showcasing a battle of wits as much as a clash of ideologies. Light's story forces us to question the nature of justice and the corrupting influence of absolute power.

Eren Yeager (Attack on Titan Season 2)

Eren's transformation in Attack on Titan Season 2 was a pivotal moment. From a fiery, vengeance-driven youth, we saw glimpses of a more strategic and, at times, desperate leader. His struggle with the Founding Titan's power and the weight of his inherited memories began to manifest, adding layers to his already complex character. The sheer burden of his existence, knowing the truth about the world and his role in it, began to take its toll. His moments of doubt and rage, juxtaposed with his unwavering commitment to his friends and humanity's survival, made him a compelling figure to watch. The existential dread that permeates Attack on Titan is embodied in Eren's journey.

Gilthunder (The Seven Deadly Sins)

Gilthunder's arc in The Seven Deadly Sins presented a fascinating study in manipulation and redemption. Initially appearing as a formidable antagonist, his actions were revealed to be a result of external influence and a desperate attempt to protect someone he cared about. His internal conflict between his programmed duty and his true feelings made him a standout character. Witnessing his struggle to break free from control and reclaim his own identity was a powerful narrative thread. This kind of character development, where perceived villains have hidden depths, is what makes anime so engaging.

Sometimes, the most memorable characters aren't the protagonists. 2017 was filled with incredible supporting cast members who, through their unique personalities, impactful moments, or sheer charisma, left an indelible mark on viewers.

Shoto Todoroki (My Hero Academia Season 2)

Todoroki's journey in 2017 was a highlight of My Hero Academia. His internal struggle with his Quirk, his abusive father Endeavor, and his desire to forge his own path resonated deeply. The Sports Festival arc, in particular, was a showcase for his character development. His duel with Midoriya wasn't just a fight; it was a clash of ideologies and a catalyst for change. Todoroki's quiet intensity, his moments of vulnerability, and his eventual willingness to confront his past made him a fan favorite and a prime example of a well-developed supporting character. His growth is a testament to the power of confronting one's own limitations.

Koro-sensei (Assassination Classroom - The final movie, "365 Days," concluded the story, but his impact in 2017 through retrospectives and fan discussions was immense.)

Koro-sensei, the beloved octopus-like teacher, is a character who embodies a unique blend of humor, wisdom, and profound sadness. His role as the target of assassination, yet simultaneously the most caring and influential teacher his students ever had, created a compelling paradox. His ultimate sacrifice, a culmination of his teachings and his genuine affection for his students, was one of the most emotionally resonant moments in recent anime history. His character arc is a powerful exploration of purpose, legacy, and the impact one individual can have on many lives. He remains a benchmark for unique and impactful characters.

Levi Ackerman (Attack on Titan Season 2)

Captain Levi, the "humanity's strongest soldier," continued to be a force to be reckoned with in 2017. His stoic demeanor, coupled with his incredible combat prowess and unwavering loyalty, made him a fan favorite. Beyond his fighting skills, however, Levi's moments of quiet contemplation and his deep-seated trauma added layers to his character. His leadership, even when facing insurmountable odds, provided a beacon of hope for many. The burden he carries, both physically and emotionally, is immense, yet he never falters. His dedication to his comrades and his relentless fight against the Titans solidified his status as one of the most iconic male characters in anime.

While complexity and anti-heroes gained prominence, the classic archetypes of the determined hero, the loyal friend, and the wise mentor also shone brightly in 2017. These characters, when executed well, provide a comforting familiarity and an aspirational quality that remains powerful.

Kirito (Sword Art Online: Ordinal Scale)

Kazuto Kirigaya, or Kirito, continued his adventures in the Sword Art Online franchise with the movie Ordinal Scale in 2017. While the series has its detractors, Kirito's consistent characterization as a skilled, protective, and often solitary figure resonated with a large fanbase. His journey through virtual worlds, facing both digital and emotional challenges, offered a unique blend of action and character introspection. His determination to protect those he cares about, even at great personal cost, is a defining trait.

Accelerator (A Certain Magical Index III - While the season aired later, the character's enduring popularity and presence in related series kept him relevant in 2017 discussions.)

Accelerator, the immensely powerful esper from A Certain Magical Index, continued to be a fascinating character study in 2017. His journey from a ruthless, psychopathic villain to a reluctant protector is one of the most compelling redemption arcs in anime. His immense power is matched only by his complex psyche, making him unpredictable and captivating. His interactions with Last Order and the various challenges he faces highlight his gradual shift in perspective and his struggle with his own nature. Can absolute power corrupt absolutely, or can it be wielded for good? Accelerator’s story suggests the latter is possible, albeit with immense difficulty.

The best anime male characters 2017 had in common was not just their strength or their charisma, but their relatability and the depth of their character arcs. Whether they were battling external monsters or their own inner demons, these characters offered viewers something to connect with, to aspire to, or to simply be entertained by on a profound level.

• Relatability: Even in fantastical settings, the best characters exhibit human flaws, desires, and fears. Saitama's boredom, Deku's self-doubt, and Guts's trauma all tap into universal human experiences.
• Growth and Development: Characters who evolve over the course of a series, learning from their mistakes and changing their perspectives, are far more engaging. Todoroki's journey to accept himself is a prime example.
• Compelling Motivations: Understanding why a character acts the way they do is crucial. Whether it's revenge, justice, protection, or a quest for meaning, clear and strong motivations drive compelling narratives.
• Impact on the Story: The best characters don't just exist; they actively shape the narrative and influence other characters. Levi's leadership and Eren's decisions are critical to the survival of humanity in Attack on Titan.

The year 2017 provided a rich tapestry of male characters, each contributing to the vibrant and ever-evolving world of anime. From the introspective struggles of heroes to the morally ambiguous actions of anti-heroes, these individuals left a lasting impression. Their stories continue to be discussed, analyzed, and celebrated, proving that well-crafted characters are the true heart of any great anime.