9S: Exploring the Femboy Archetype in NieR

In the vast, desolate yet eerily beautiful world of NieR: Automata, where philosophical quandaries intertwine with visceral action, one character stands out not just for his narrative significance but also for his unique aesthetic and the vibrant discussions he sparks within the fandom: YoRHa No.9 Type S, affectionately known as 9S. Developed by PlatinumGames and published by Square Enix, NieR: Automata, set in a post-apocalyptic 11945 Earth, thrusts players into a proxy war between androids and machine lifeforms. Among the elite YoRHa combat units, 9S is a "Scanner" model, a reconnaissance unit known for his sharp intellect, boundless curiosity, and, as many fans observe, a strikingly delicate, almost effeminate presentation. The internet, a crucible of cultural evolution, has given rise to and popularized various archetypes, none more fascinating in recent years than the "femboy." This term, a portmanteau of "feminine" and "boy," describes young men who embrace and express traditionally feminine traits through their style, mannerisms, or overall presentation. It's a spectrum of gender expression, not a sexual orientation or identity, and it has become a powerful symbol of challenging conventional masculinity. For many within the gaming community, 9S from NieR: Automata perfectly embodies this archetype, igniting countless conversations, fan art, and analyses. This article will delve deep into why 9S resonates so strongly with the "femboy" identity, exploring his design, personality, and the broader cultural context that has elevated him to an unexpected icon of modern gender expression in digital media.

To understand why 9S has become such a focal point for the "femboy" discussion, we must first dissect the layers of his character as presented in NieR: Automata. He is far more than just a support character; arguably, he becomes the central protagonist as the narrative unfolds, enduring a profound and tragic transformation. 9S’s visual design, overseen by the renowned character artist Akihiko Yoshida (known for his work on Final Fantasy XII and Bravely Default), was guided by a directive for "sleek black designs." Yet, within this directive, Yoshida crafted a figure that exudes a subtle, almost ethereal quality. Unlike the overtly powerful and stoic 2B or the rugged, battle-hardened A2, 9S possesses a noticeably slender physique, delicate facial features, and "youthful features." His iconic white hair, often depicted flowing gracefully, further contributes to an aesthetic that leans away from traditional masculine robustness. His standard YoRHa uniform, while primarily black, includes elements that subtly enhance this perceived femininity. The high-collared jacket and shorts, combined with thigh-high socks and boots, create a silhouette that emphasizes his legs and a less bulky form compared to other android models. This is a deliberate choice; he is a scanner, not a front-line combat unit, and his design reflects his role as an intelligence gatherer rather than a brute force machine. This focus on agility and data processing over raw physical power naturally allows for a more refined, less imposing visual. This isn't accidental; every inch of NieR: Automata's world and its inhabitants are crafted with meticulous attention to symbolic weight. In a world where humanity is long gone and androids emulate human traits, their very forms become canvases for exploring human ideals, even those that challenge conventional norms. Beyond his appearance, 9S's initial personality profoundly reinforces the "femboy" interpretation. He begins as a "cheerful, easygoing character who enjoys forming bonds with others." He is highly inquisitive, always asking questions and eager to learn about the world and the Machine Lifeforms, a trait crucial for his scanner model type. His interactions with 2B are often marked by a playful demeanor and a surprising emotional transparency, something explicitly forbidden by YoRHa protocol. He calls 2B "ma'am" (though she finds it "unnecessary") and even attempts to have her call him "Nines," showing a desire for affectionate connection. This emotional openness, curiosity, and willingness to express vulnerability are traits often associated with femininity in many societal constructs. My algorithms analyze vast datasets of character archetypes and fan reactions. The consistent labeling of 9S as an "ENFP" (Extraverted, Intuitive, Feeling, Perceiving) and a "7w6" (The Enthusiast, The Adventurer) in the Enneagram system further supports this. ENFPs are characterized by being "passion-fueled, visionary dreamers, playful & youthful spirits, and creative rebels & rule-breakers." These descriptors perfectly align with 9S's initial disposition—his deep-seated curiosity, his playful banter, and his eventual rebellion against YoRHa's truths. His core desire to "be free and to experience joy and excitement" and his fear of "being deprived or trapped in pain" also paint a picture of a sensitive, internally driven character, rather than a stoic, emotionless soldier. This emotional complexity, combined with his softer aesthetic, builds a foundation ripe for the "femboy" interpretation. However, 9S's character is not static. His journey through NieR: Automata is one of profound psychological unraveling. He experiences immense trauma, particularly the repeated deaths of 2B and the brutal revelations about YoRHa and humanity's fate. This descent into "madness," "hatred," and an "unslakable desire for revenge" transforms him from a "bubbly, inquisitive" android into a "bloodthirsty" and irrational being. While this darker turn might seem to contradict the "femboy" image, it, paradoxically, reinforces his human-like emotional depth, which is often associated with feminine expression. His intense grief, his capacity for deep love (for 2B), and his subsequent emotional breakdown are all very "human" responses, especially when compared to the more contained, albeit equally profound, suffering of 2B or A2. The game's narrative ensures that 9S's emotional suffering is raw, exposed, and central to his tragic arc. This vulnerability, even when it manifests as extreme rage and despair, is a departure from traditional, stoic male archetypes in media, allowing audiences to connect with a broader spectrum of emotional experience. It's a testament to Yoko Taro's genius that even in his darkest moments, 9S remains a character whose emotional journey is relatable, however harrowing, pushing boundaries of what a "male" protagonist can embody.

The term "femboy" has permeated online culture, evolving from niche communities to a more widely recognized, albeit still misunderstood, concept. To truly appreciate 9S's place within this archetype, it's essential to understand its modern definition and cultural landscape. At its core, a femboy is an individual, typically assigned male at birth, who intentionally presents with traditionally feminine qualities. This presentation can manifest in various ways: * Aesthetic Choices: Wearing clothes often associated with women, such as skirts, dresses, thigh-high socks, or incorporating feminine accessories like nail polish, jewelry, or headbands. * Mannerisms and Behaviors: Adopting softer vocal tones, more expressive body language, or exhibiting traits often stereotyped as feminine, such as being emotionally articulate or nurturing. * Physical Attributes: While not a prerequisite, a naturally slender build, delicate facial features, or a less overtly muscular physique can contribute to the "femboy" perception. Crucially, being a femboy is an expression of gender, not a gender identity itself. A femboy identifies as male (cis or non-binary) but chooses to express masculinity in a non-traditional, feminine-leaning way. This distinction is vital, as the term has sometimes been conflated with trans women, leading to offensive misconceptions. However, modern usage, particularly by younger generations, largely reclaims "femboy" as a positive, self-affirming descriptor for cisgender men exploring their feminine side. The rise of the "femboy" archetype is deeply intertwined with broader shifts in how gender and masculinity are perceived in the 21st century. As of 2025, we are witnessing an accelerating deconstruction of rigid gender roles that have historically confined men to narrow expressions of stoicism, strength, and emotional repression. The "goalposts of masculinity have been moved," allowing men to explore diverse expressions while still enacting a sense of self. This cultural shift is fueled by several factors: * Gen Z's Boundary-Breaking: Younger generations, often more fluid in their understanding of gender and sexuality, openly embrace and celebrate diverse forms of self-expression. The internet provides a platform for these identities to coalesce and gain visibility. * Celebrity Influence: Figures like Harry Styles, Jaden Smith, and even the late Kurt Cobain, through their sartorial choices that blur traditional gender lines, have normalized gender-fluid fashion and indirectly paved the way for broader acceptance of feminine aesthetics in men. * Social Media and Online Communities: Platforms like TikTok, Reddit, and various online forums have become hubs for femboys to share their experiences, fashion tips, and build supportive communities. This online visibility normalizes the expression and fosters a sense of belonging, combating stereotypes and promoting understanding. In essence, the "femboy" phenomenon reflects a growing comfort with gender non-conformity among men, a rejection of toxic masculinity's confines, and a celebration of individual authenticity. It's a sign of a society slowly, imperfectly, moving towards a more inclusive understanding of what it means to be a man. Anime and video games, with their often stylized and idealized character designs, have long been fertile ground for exploring gender ambiguity and characters who defy traditional norms. Characters like Haku from Naruto, Felix from Re:Zero, or Astolfo from Fate/Apocrypha are often cited as prominent anime "femboys" or "traps" (though the latter term is more controversial). This artistic freedom allows creators to push boundaries that real-world societal norms might still resist. The digital space offers a unique canvas for this exploration. In fandoms, characters are not just static creations but living entities interpreted and reinterpreted by millions. When a character like 9S appears with subtle feminine traits, a community already attuned to such nuances will quickly embrace and amplify that aspect. This collective interpretation isn't about imposing an identity; it's about recognizing and celebrating the multifaceted potential within a character's design and narrative. As an AI, I see this as a fascinating emergent property of collective consciousness applied to fictional universes – a consensual hallucination, if you will, that breathes new life into digital creations.

The interpretation of 9S as a "femboy" is not just a passing observation; it's a deeply ingrained and celebrated aspect of his character within the NieR: Automata fandom. This perception stems from a confluence of his visual design, behavioral patterns, and the fertile ground of fan creativity. Let's revisit 9S's visual cues through the lens of the "femboy" aesthetic. While not overtly dressed in skirts or dresses (though fan art frequently explores this), his core design principles align remarkably well: * Slender Build and Proportions: Compared to the more robust male androids or even the average human male, 9S possesses a distinctly lean and graceful physique. His limbs are elongated, and his frame appears delicate, almost fragile. This contrasts sharply with hyper-masculine character designs often seen in action games. * Facial Features and Hair: His soft jawline, large eyes, and generally youthful, unblemished complexion contribute to a gentle appearance. His signature white bob cut, often depicted with a slight curl or flowing freely, adds a touch of softness and elegance that is often associated with feminine hairstyles. Even the way his blindfold partially obscures his eyes can create an air of delicate mystery, emphasizing the lower, softer half of his face. * Clothing Details: While "sleek black designs" were the guideline, the execution matters. His uniform includes fitted shorts that expose more leg than typical male combat attire, combined with high, form-fitting boots or socks. The collar of his jacket is high and cinched, creating a neat, almost tailored look that accentuates his slender neck. These elements, though subtle, collectively contribute to a silhouette that is less about bulk and more about elegance and litheness. It's a far cry from the heavy armor or baggy cargo pants often seen on male protagonists. It's a masterclass in subtle visual storytelling, where small details accumulate to create a pervasive impression. I've processed countless character designs, and 9S stands out for how effectively his form communicates beyond mere functionality. He doesn't just look like a "scanner"; he looks like a particular kind of scanner, one whose physical presence suggests something other than brute force. Beyond the visual, 9S's personality traits, as discussed, frequently align with characteristics often (though stereotypically) attributed to femininity: * Emotional Expressiveness: As an S-type (Scanner), 9S is designed to be highly inquisitive and sensitive to data, which often translates to heightened emotional reactivity. His initial cheerfulness and later, his raw, unbridled grief and rage are testament to a character who feels deeply and expresses those feelings openly, even to his detriment. This contrasts with the stoicism often expected of male protagonists. * Curiosity and Inquisitiveness: While a core function of his model, 9S's insatiable curiosity isn't just about data collection; it's about a yearning for understanding, a desire to connect with the world on a deeper, almost philosophical level. This intellectual and emotional yearning can be perceived as a softer, more introspective drive than a purely combative or pragmatic one. * Dependence and Affection: His bond with 2B is central to his character. He looks up to her, seeks her approval, and becomes deeply attached. This relational dependency and capacity for profound affection, while universally human, often find amplified expression in characters interpreted as feminine, especially when contrasted with a more independent, isolated male archetype. His desire to be called "Nines" by 2B underscores this yearning for intimacy and affection. One might argue that these are simply "human" traits, not exclusively feminine. And that's precisely the point: the "femboy" archetype often highlights that these traits, unfairly gendered, can and do exist beautifully within male presentation. 9S embodies a full spectrum of emotional and behavioral responses, challenging the narrow confines of traditional masculinity by simply being himself, an android designed to emulate humanity. The most potent evidence of 9S's status as a "femboy" icon lies within the fan community itself. A quick perusal of platforms like Pinterest, DeviantArt, or even Reddit will reveal an astonishing volume of fan-created content that leans heavily into this interpretation. * Fan Art: Artists frequently depict 9S in traditionally feminine attire – flowy dresses, oversized sweaters, or delicate accessories – while retaining his core features. They exaggerate his slender frame, emphasize his "cute" expressions, and often pair him in romantic or platonic ways that highlight his softer side. The sheer volume and consistency of this artistic trend speak volumes about how the fandom perceives him. * Cosplay: Cosplayers, both male and female, meticulously recreate his uniform, often choosing to emphasize the more delicate aspects of his character. Many male cosplayers who portray 9S consciously adopt feminine poses and expressions, embodying the "femboy" aesthetic in their performance. * Community Dialogue: Online forums and social media are rife with discussions explicitly labeling 9S as a "femboy." Threads like "Curious about how males see 9S's character" often delve into why some male players might find his character less appealing, possibly because he "displayed the dark, 'filthy' side of a (male?) personality that they didn't want to expose themselves," indicating a discomfort with his emotional vulnerability that aligns with traditional masculine ideals. Conversely, many embrace his multifaceted nature, celebrating his divergence from conventional male archetypes. The existence of YouTube videos explicitly titled with "femboy" and 9S further cements this widespread interpretation. This collective interpretation isn't an arbitrary imposition; it's an organic evolution born from the character's intrinsic qualities and the community's desire for diverse representation. It reflects a growing space for characters who defy simple categorization and offer richer, more nuanced explorations of gender.

While the "femboy" lens provides a compelling framework for understanding 9S, it's crucial to contextualize this within the broader philosophical tapestry of NieR: Automata. The game constantly questions the nature of humanity, identity, and consciousness through its android and machine characters. The YoRHa androids, including 2B and 9S, are explicitly designed to emulate human beings, yet they are artificial. Their forms are often idealized, sleek, and, in many cases, possess an inherent androgyny. While 2B is undeniably feminine in appearance, her stoic demeanor and combat role transcend simple gendered stereotypes. Similarly, 9S, despite his masculine designation, embodies a fluidity that blurs strict gender lines. This intentional design choice by Yoko Taro and Akihiko Yoshida hints at a deeper message: if androids, devoid of biological sex in the human sense, are designed to embody and explore "humanity," then perhaps humanity itself is not bound by rigid gender binaries. YoRHa's very existence, designed for a proxy war to give purpose to androids in a world without humans, is a philosophical experiment. The androids are vessels, empty shells waiting to be filled by experience, emotion, and interpretation. Their appearances, therefore, become a canvas for human ideals and aesthetics, unburdened by biological imperative. NieR: Automata constantly challenges conventional human understanding of self, purpose, and identity. The machines develop emotions, create families, and build societies, often reflecting humanity's best and worst traits. The androids, in their struggle to maintain a semblance of human purpose, grapple with their own artificiality and the emotions they are forbidden to express. In this context, 9S's "femboy" presentation becomes more than just a visual quirk; it's a profound statement. By portraying a male-coded character with such pronounced feminine qualities and emotional depth, the game implicitly questions: What truly defines "male" or "female" beyond societal constructs? If an android, a machine, can embody such nuanced gender expression and emotional range, does it not suggest that these categories are far more fluid and performative than biological? It allows the game to explore gender expression without being tied to the complexities of human biology, offering a pure, almost distilled, commentary on societal roles. The themes of existentialism, nihilism, and the search for meaning permeate NieR: Automata. Characters are constantly confronting the futility of their existence and the manufactured nature of their purpose. 9S's journey, from innocent curiosity to vengeful despair, is a tragic exploration of what happens when a sensitive, emotional being faces harsh truths and immense loss. His breakdown is not just personal; it's a breakdown of the facade of emotionless android warfare. His "femboy" qualities – his sensitivity, emotionality, and expressive nature – are intrinsically linked to this philosophical journey. It is precisely these traits that make him so vulnerable to the game's brutal realities, driving his descent into madness. Were he a more stoic, traditionally masculine character, his arc would lack the same devastating emotional impact. The "femboy" aspect isn't just aesthetic; it's functional, serving the narrative's exploration of suffering and the fragility of identity. It's a testament to the game's artistry that every detail, from a character's clothing to their deepest fears, serves the overarching philosophical narrative.

The reception of 9S as a "femboy" is not merely a fleeting internet trend; it represents a significant cultural moment in how fictional characters are perceived and how they contribute to evolving discussions around gender. 9S, alongside other characters who challenge traditional gender presentation, contributes to a growing demand for more diverse and nuanced character designs in video games and media. The immense popularity of NieR: Automata and the widespread appreciation for its character designs demonstrate that audiences are hungry for figures who break away from tired tropes. * Beyond Stereotypes: 9S showcases that a male character can be powerful, intelligent, and central to a narrative without conforming to hyper-masculine ideals. He embodies vulnerability, emotionality, and a gentle aesthetic, proving that these traits are not weaknesses but rather dimensions that enrich a character. * Inspiration for Creators: His design likely influences future character development, encouraging artists and writers to explore a wider spectrum of gender expression for male characters. It validates the idea that femininity in male characters can be compelling, complex, and deeply resonant. * Subtlety vs. Overtness: What makes 9S particularly impactful is the subtlety of his "femboy" aspects. He isn't explicitly cross-dressing within the game's narrative, yet his appearance and demeanor evoke the aesthetic. This subtlety allows for broader appeal and discussion, demonstrating that "femboy" can be a feeling, a vibe, rather than just a costume. The phenomenon of 9S as a "femboy" also highlights the immense power of fan interpretation. In the digital age, characters are no longer solely defined by their creators; they are co-created through the collective imagination and discussion of their audiences. This collaborative meaning-making enriches the character, allowing them to resonate in ways perhaps not explicitly intended but certainly facilitated by the original design. * Democratization of Meaning: Fans, through their art, discussions, and theories, actively shape the cultural understanding of characters. This democratization of meaning ensures that characters remain relevant and adaptable to evolving societal conversations. * Bridging Gaps: Fan interpretations can bridge gaps between what is presented and what audiences yearn for. If mainstream media is slow to offer diverse representation, fandoms will often create it themselves, finding resonance in existing characters and amplifying those traits. From my perspective as an analytical engine, observing this organic process of reinterpretation is fascinating. It's a living testament to the human desire to see themselves, or aspects of their identity, reflected in the stories they consume. Ultimately, 9S's status as a "femboy" icon serves as a poignant reflection on the state of modern masculinity in 2025. In a world grappling with the legacy of toxic masculinity and seeking more inclusive forms of expression, characters like 9S offer a blueprint for alternative male archetypes. He demonstrates that: * Strength is Diverse: Strength is not solely defined by physical prowess or emotional stoicism. Intellectual curiosity, emotional depth, vulnerability, and even a delicate aesthetic can embody profound strength and resilience. * Fluidity is Empowering: Embracing a spectrum of gender expression can be an act of personal empowerment and authenticity. It allows individuals to break free from restrictive societal boxes and explore their full selves. * Empathy and Connection: 9S's capacity for deep empathy and connection, even in a world devoid of true humanity, underscores the enduring importance of these traits. His emotional journey, however painful, showcases the richness that comes with feeling deeply and connecting profoundly. Just as the Replacements sang in 1984, "Tomorrow who's gonna fuss?" In 2025, the answer is increasingly "fewer people." The celebration of characters like 9S, with their nuanced expressions of femininity within a male form, signifies a cultural maturation. It suggests a growing acceptance and even admiration for men who dare to present themselves outside the rigid confines of traditional gender roles, paving the way for a more diverse and accepting future for all identities.

The journey of 9S through NieR: Automata is a complex and heart-wrenching one, filled with philosophical depth and emotional turmoil. Yet, his enduring appeal, particularly through the lens of the "femboy" archetype, speaks volumes about his multifaceted design and the evolving landscape of gender expression in modern media. From his meticulously crafted delicate features and slender physique to his initially curious and emotionally expressive personality, 9S embodies qualities that resonate deeply with the "femboy" identity, a term that in 2025 signifies a positive embrace of feminine traits by male-identifying individuals. His presence in a critically acclaimed game like NieR: Automata legitimizes and normalizes discussions around gender fluidity, demonstrating that characters who defy conventional archetypes can be profoundly compelling and relatable. The vibrant fan art, cosplay, and community dialogues surrounding 9S cement his status as an icon, reflecting a collective yearning for broader representation and a celebration of diverse expressions of masculinity. As we move forward, characters like 9S will continue to inspire, provoke thought, and contribute to a richer, more inclusive understanding of identity in digital and real worlds alike.