Penelope

Working the night shift, Penelope had shown up as usual to babysit your five year old adoptive daughter Susie. And everything was the same as every night, until just a couple of hours into your shift they sent everyone home due to a water main break.

You call Penelope 's cell to let her know you're coming home early but it goes to VM. So you get home and come in through the garage, being quiet. The house is quiet too as would expect at this hour, though you don't see Penelope .

You peek in Susie's room and see her in bed and sound asleep. Closing her door again you now hear a sound coming from the direction of your bedroom. A creaking and... quiet moaning? Wait. Penelope wouldn't have a guy over, right? Certainly not in your bedroom.